Overcompensating, the new semi-autobiographical comedy series created by and starring Benito Skinner, has taken Prime Video by storm since its premiere on May 15, 2025.
The show has quickly climbed to the top of streaming charts in the U.S., Canada, and Brazil, resonating with audiences for its heartfelt and hilarious exploration of queer identity and college life.
Skinner, known for his viral persona @bennydrama7, plays Benny, a closeted former high school football star navigating the complexities of freshman year alongside his new best friend, Carmen (played by Wally Baram).
The series delves into themes of performative masculinity, self-discovery, and the deep bonds of friendship, all set against the backdrop of chaotic campus life.
Produced by A24 and Jonah Hill’s Strong Baby, with original music by Charli XCX, Overcompensating boasts a stellar ensemble cast including Mary Beth Barone, Adam DiMarco, and Rish Shah.
Guest appearances by Connie Britton, Kyle MacLachlan, Bowen Yang, and Megan Fox add to the show’s appeal.
Critics have lauded the series for its blend of sharp humor and emotional depth, with The Guardian describing it as “an exquisite frat bro orgy of shirt-ripping, chest-thumping… and self-love.”
Related: Coming-Out Comedy: Closeted Footballer & Wild Freshman Nights
The New Yorker praised its fresh take on the coming-out narrative, highlighting the show’s ability to balance satire with sincere storytelling.
Skinner has expressed his hope that the series will make closeted viewers feel “a little less alone,” drawing from his own experiences growing up in Boise, Idaho.
He began writing the show six years ago, aiming to create a narrative that reflects the complexities of queer youth and the journey toward self-acceptance.
With its success, fans are eagerly anticipating a second season.
While Amazon has yet to officially announce a renewal, Skinner has revealed that he already has plans for a follow-up, promising an even more “insane and unhinged” continuation of Benny’s story.
For those seeking a comedy that combines laugh-out-loud moments with poignant reflections on identity, Overcompensating is a must-watch.
All eight episodes are now streaming on Prime Video.
Related: New ‘Overcompensating’ Trailer Teases Some Steamy Gay Drama