Post may include affiliate links, which may earn us a commission
It’s been 14 years since that life-changing night when Thomas McKay first spent the night at PJ’s house, but for Thomas, the memories are as vivid as ever.
Four years ago today, on their 10th anniversary, Thomas opened up in a heartfelt post about that unforgettable night—the night that marked the beginning of a love story that has since become an inspiration to so many of us in the LGBTQ+ community.
“I was a nervous wreck,” he admitted. “I had never told anyone I was gay before, and I had no idea how PJ would react.”
In his post, Thomas described the anxiety that filled his stomach with knots as he made the decision to spend the night at PJ’s house.
“We’d been texting nonstop for two days, and I just kept wondering, ‘Is this really happening? Does he even like me, or am I just setting myself up for heartbreak?’” he recalled.
“But there was something about PJ—something about the way he made me feel like it was okay to be myself—that made me take the risk.”
And what a risk it was. That night, in PJ’s cozy little house, they talked for hours, sharing stories and dreams, getting to know each other in a way that felt so natural, yet so new.
“We didn’t even finish the movie we started,” Thomas laughed. “I think we were both too caught up in the moment to care.”
For many of us, Thomas and PJ’s story is deeply relatable—the fear, the excitement, the uncertainty of opening up to someone for the first time.
Thomas confessed that he was terrified PJ might not feel the same way, or worse, that he was just being kind out of pity.
“I kept thinking, ‘What does this successful, confident guy see in me, a skinny 19-year-old still living at home with his mom?’ It felt too good to be true.”
+Related: PJ & Thomas Celebrate 5 Years as Foster Dads
But it wasn’t. As Thomas discovered the next morning, PJ felt just as strongly.
“I woke up to an empty house and thought I’d blown it,” Thomas remembered. “But then I saw this note he left for me on the back of an envelope, and all those doubts I had just disappeared. That note—it gave me hope.”
Over the next few days, their connection only deepened.
They texted constantly, met up in secret, and slowly but surely, their bond grew stronger.
“Those early days were exhilarating and scary all at once,” Thomas said. “But looking back, I wouldn’t change a thing. PJ gave me the courage to be who I really was—to come out to my family and friends and start living the life I’d always dreamed of.”
Now, as they celebrate 14 years together, Thomas and PJ are still the couple that so many of us admire.
They’ve built a life in the small Southern town that once felt suffocating but has now become their haven.
“PJ helped me see this place in a different light,” Thomas reflected. “He made me realize that it’s not where you are, but who you’re with, that really matters.”
Their journey hasn’t been without its challenges, but through it all, they’ve remained each other’s rock.
“I’m just so grateful for him,” Thomas said, his voice full of emotion. “PJ showed me what it means to love and be loved fully. He’s my helper, my partner, my best friend.”
Here’s to Thomas and PJ—14 years of love, growth, and countless memories.
Their story is a reminder that love can be found in the most unexpected places, and sometimes, all it takes is a little courage to step out of the shadows and into the light.
+Related: Neil Patrick and David Celebrate 20 Year Anniversary