Benito Skinner, a gay comedian who first found fame online through his hilarious “Bennity Drama” sketches and viral celebrity impressions, is stepping into new territory with Overcompensating.
Set to premiere on Prime Video on May 15, this heartfelt and uproarious series marks a significant leap in Skinner’s career, as he not only stars but also serves as the creator, writer, and executive producer.
At the heart of Overcompensating is Benny, a closeted former football star and homecoming king trying to adapt to life as a freshman in college.
He wrestles with concealing his identity while juggling classes, friendships, and the general chaos of campus life.
Despite his athletic background, Benny soon realizes that his new environment poses entirely different challenges, including late-night cram sessions, awkward dorm encounters, and parties that push the limits of his comfort zone.
As he navigates these uncharted waters, Benny receives both guidance and comic relief from his sister, played by Mary Beth Barone, whose brand of tough love is as entertaining as it is earnest.
She arrives on campus with her longtime boyfriend, portrayed by Adam DiMarco, a laid-back college legend who encourages Benny to step out of his shell and embrace the unexpected.
The familial support continues with a pair of comedic powerhouses: Connie Britton and Kyle MacLachlan, who step into the roles of Benny’s parents, Kathryn and John.
Their presence in Overcompensating provides a warm counterbalance to the college hijinks, offering insight into the pressures Benny feels from his upbringing.
Rounding out the cast are notable talents like Kaia Gerber and Owen Thiele, each bringing an extra dose of humor and flair to Benny’s ever-expanding social circle.
Adding even more star power is Charli XCX, who curates the show’s soundtrack, infusing each scene with an energetic, modern beat that matches the exuberance of the characters.
Her cameo in the series is rumored to be as spirited as her music, further enhancing the already vibrant atmosphere.
While Overcompensating promises plenty of laugh-out-loud moments—like a raucous toga party or cringe-worthy attempts at flirting—it also delves into the deeper theme of self-discovery.
Benny’s struggle with identity reflects many real-life experiences, particularly for LGBTQIA+ youth who grapple with acceptance, both internally and externally.
+Related: Ex-Rutgers Star Jake Eldridge Gets Real About Coming Out
In interviews, Benito Skinner has revealed that the show’s semi-autobiographical slant draws inspiration from his own freshman year misadventures, though the comedic stakes are heightened for maximum effect.
He explained that the process of writing Overcompensating was both cathartic and eye-opening, allowing him to craft a story that resonates with anyone who has ever felt uncertain about where they belong.
For audiences seeking a blend of big laughs, heartfelt moments, and an authentic portrayal of LGBTQ+ life, Overcompensating checks all the boxes.
Its witty dialogue, colorful characters, and boundary-pushing parties capture the essence of college life while ensuring the journey feels both personal and universal.
With Benito Skinner at the helm, viewers can expect a unique mix of irreverent humor and genuine warmth.
From the locker room to the lecture hall, Overcompensating invites audiences to witness Benny’s evolution as he discovers that sometimes, the biggest obstacle to happiness is our own fear.
When May 15 arrives, tune in to Prime Video for a wild ride filled with comedic twists, poignant revelations, and a killer soundtrack that will have you dancing in your living room.
It is a fresh, fun, and fearless look at growing up, growing bolder, and learning that we are all just trying to figure ourselves out—one misstep at a time.