It looks like the holiday spirit is sticking around for another season!
Hallmark has officially renewed Finding Mr. Christmas for a second season, with our favorite holiday host, Jonathan Bennett, back to lead the festive search for love.
The show, which became a surprise holiday hit last year, combines the magic of matchmaking with the glitz of Christmas cheer, proving that yuletide romance is alive and well.
In an exclusive with People, Jonathan teased that they’re “just scratching the surface” when it comes to finding heartwarming stories and eligible bachelors who embody the spirit of the season.
And let’s be honest—no one does holiday sparkle quite like Jonathan Bennett.
From his days as Aaron Samuels in Mean Girls to becoming the king of queer Christmas movies (The Holiday Sitter, anyone?), Bennett has truly become Hallmark’s holly-jolly MVP.
The show’s first season charmed viewers with its blend of heartfelt moments, cozy settings, and a sprinkle of LGBTQ+ representation that felt authentic and refreshing.
Fans are already speculating about what’s in store for Season 2. Will we see more diversity in the contestants?
A surprise celebrity guest? Or maybe even some tear-jerking proposals under the mistletoe?
+Related: Watch Hubby’s Super Cute Reaction to Jonathan Bennett’s First Role
One thing’s for sure—Jonathan’s enthusiasm for spreading joy is infectious.
As he said in his announcement: “Christmas is the time to believe in love, and I can’t wait to help more people find theirs.”
With his signature charisma, those dreamy Hallmark sets, and a lineup of eligible suitors, it’s safe to say that Finding Mr. Christmas is bound to deliver another season of holiday magic.
And let’s not forget, Jonathan and his husband, Jaymes Vaughan, are holiday royalty themselves!
The power couple has been a beacon of love and positivity for the LGBTQ+ community, and Jonathan’s continued success is proof that being your authentic self is always in season.
So, grab your hot cocoa, put on your coziest pajamas, and get ready to swoon—because the search for Mr. Christmas is coming back, and we couldn’t be more excited!
What do you think? Too much tinsel or just the right amount of sparkle?
+Related: Merry & Bright: 10 Must-Watch Gay Christmas Movies