The boy next door is another boy. Their mothers have a plan. And a musical that spent decades charming audiences Off-Broadway has finally made the trip uptown.
The Fantasticks opened at Broadway’s Hayes Theater on November 16, with a romance between Matt and Lewis at its heart.
For a show that first opened Off-Broadway in 1960, that is quite a new chapter.

The mothers are matchmaking
In Second Stage’s production, Maxim Chlumecky plays Matt and Nathan Levy plays Lewis, the character originally written as Luisa.
The original’s two scheming fathers have become two mothers, played by Leslie Rodriguez Kritzer and Ruthie Ann Miles. They pretend to oppose their sons’ romance, banking on the idea that forbidding something makes it irresistible.
So the parental interference here comes with a delightful twist: these mothers want their boys to fall for each other. They simply have a spectacularly roundabout way of encouraging it.

Written into the story by its creator
This revision has a history well before the current Broadway opening.
Tom Jones, the musical’s original book writer and lyricist, collaborated with director Michael Lluberes on the version that premiered at Flint Repertory Theatre in Michigan in June 2022.
As American Theatre reported at the time, Lluberes approached Jones about reimagining the lovers as two young men. Jones embraced the idea and worked on detailed changes to the scenes and lyrics.
Jones died in 2023. His revised work, alongside Harvey Schmidt’s music, now reaches Broadway under director and choreographer Christopher Gattelli.
A friendship behind the romance
There is also a warm connection between the actors playing the lovers.
In an October interview with Theatrely, Levy and Chlumecky explained that they met through Pace University. Levy even stayed in Chlumecky’s dorm during a prospective-student visit.
Despite knowing each other through their college years, they had never performed in a show together. This production finally gives those longtime friends a shared stage.
Early responses include Attitude’s warm review, while other critics have raised reservations about parts of the older material and its move to a larger setting. The production has prompted discussion as well as affection.
For gay audiences, though, the central invitation is appealingly simple: a familiar musical romance can make room for two young men, their longing and their meddling mothers.
After 66 years, the boy next door gets a different duet.
📷 Joan Marcus


