HomeGay BuzzThe Traitors’ Gay Cowboy Ben McDonnell Found an Unexpected Sense of Belonging

Related Posts

BGay Trivia Quiz

Which singer/actor starred in "The Normal Heart" and "American Horror Story"?

The Traitors’ Gay Cowboy Ben McDonnell Found an Unexpected Sense of Belonging

Ben McDonnell has plenty of entertaining stories about filming The Traitors: New Blood. But the one that stays with you concerns something quieter than the elaborate missions and suspicious glances: feeling comfortable in a group of men.

The Texas barrel racer and actor has been reflecting on the unexpected emotional side of his Scottish castle experience.

“I didn’t think they were going to love me for me,” he told The Hollywood Reporter.

A cowboy without the costume

In a separate interview with Attitude, McDonnell described how experiences growing up gay had made male friendships and traditionally masculine spaces feel complicated.

In the castle, he found men who accepted his personality without requiring him to tone it down. The familiarity of being included reached a part of him he hadn’t fully realised still needed it.

For readers who remember monitoring their voice, their gestures or how much of themselves to reveal in a room, that is an easily recognisable feeling.

His cowboy identity is no television invention. McDonnell told Attitude he has ridden horses and competed in barrel racing for more than 20 years.

He is also a trained performer. His official biography describes acting training at The Groundlings and with Lesly Kahn, alongside a screen credit in Concussion.

The ranch and the acting career are both parts of the same man.

Home with AJ—and rather a lot of animals

McDonnell and his partner, AJ, run BEAJ Ranch, an animal sanctuary whose name combines their own. He told Attitude that they care for more than 70 animals.

That gives the story a life beyond the castle: a shared home, horses and the decidedly unglamorous responsibility of keeping animals fed and paying vet bills.

There is, however, one addition with a particularly theatrical connection.

Their new piglet is named Alan CunningHam, after host Alan Cumming. McDonnell told THR that he sent Cumming photographs and explained the tribute.

A small pig with a name ready for a dressing-room door feels entirely appropriate.

The man holding the room

McDonnell also praised Cumming’s commitment to the show, describing round-table sessions that can last around two hours, with the host staying in character throughout.

For an actor watching another performer work, that offered its own kind of inspiration.

New Blood is the US franchise’s all-civilian edition. NBC has renewed it for a second season in 2027, with Cumming returning.

But McDonnell’s reflections offer a reason to care beyond the mechanics of the game. Sometimes being welcomed into the circle can mean more than anyone watching from outside would guess.

📷 @mcdonnellben @ajsarcione

Mood Meter

Did you enjoy the article?

Latest Posts